MyGov - Discussion thread for GST

MyGov - Discussion thread for GST
Start Date :
Jun 30, 2017
Last Date :
Aug 16, 2017
00:00 AM IST (GMT +5.30 Hrs)
Submission Closed

With the GST coming into effect from 1st July, 2017, the biggest indirect tax reform of independent India, is going to transform the way indirect tax is administered in this ...

With the GST coming into effect from 1st July, 2017, the biggest indirect tax reform of independent India, is going to transform the way indirect tax is administered in this country, impacting not just businesses but also the common man. GST is a tax on consumption of goods and services, which is levied at all stages right from manufacturing up to final consumption, with credit of taxes paid at previous stages available as setoff. It is going to remove the tax-on-tax effect through separate Central and State tax laws. In a nutshell, under GST, only value addition will be taxed , hence, reducing the burden of tax to be borne by the final consumer.

The most fundamental change in GST besides the consolidation of multiple taxes, is the use of a robust shared IT infrastructure in its operations. All the forms related to registrations, filing returns and other related activities can now be done through the GSTN Portal.

GST will help build an economically stronger India, with 'One Nation, One Tax, One Market.' - Click here to know more about GST

Click here to read FAQs

Showing 840 Submission(s)
Nagendra Kumar Biyani
Baas Image 460
Nagendra Kumar Biyani 5 years 1 month ago

GST on Flats Purchase 18% is very high and prohibitive to take any flat by a common middle class man. Earlier it was around 4 % which itself is very high given the high cost of real estate products. We are now forced to close our agreements for purchase of flats since the GST itslef boosted the price by whooping 18% and comes around addnl burden of Rs 5.00 lakhs small flat.It is horrible.You can say that input tax credits will reduce the burden. In India will Real Estate ever transfer?
Baas Image 273950
SUBHASH CHANDRA MALLICK 5 years 1 month ago

When we do something new, We may committed some mistake. but I always appreciate new ideas & new thoughts. Plz go on and think forward. The mistakes will be corrected in future and our thinks/ideas should be superfast. Plz think ahead & never look backward.

Baas Image 820
Sahu_1 5 years 1 month ago

As now a days every shop is collecting GST 18% to 28%, and we are paying happily. Did the money goes to GOVT, no clue. There should be some connection we should send a photo copy of receipt that we paid GST, So Gove can randomly verify Yes the GST received by GOVE, else the money is looting by so many shop kippers.
Baas Image 1700
Jitendra Singh 5 years 1 month ago

Agencies/Individuals giving inter state service & business is below 20 lacs should be exempted from GST. We are finding it difficult to hire trainers from outside Gujarat who do not fall under GST. But they have to take GST number for giving inter state services.

Baas Image 340
RIDHDHISH VORA 5 years 1 month ago

GST Return - हर महीने खत्म होते ही 10 दीनमें जो सेल की डीटेईल डालनी उस मसय मर्यादा को बढाने की जरूरत है.
वो 10 की जगह 20 दीन की जानी चाहीए.आप वेसेभी प्रोविजनल क्रेडीट दे रहे है तो क्यु ना रीर्टन की सारी डीटेईल अपलोड करने हेतु 20 दीन मीले.अगर कोई मीसमेच है तो आप नेक्स्ट महीने की अगली रीर्टन में वो टेक्स क्रेडीट टेक्स पेटर से रीर्वर्स करवा सकते है.

Baas Image 340
RIDHDHISH VORA 5 years 1 month ago

ईनवोईस मेचींग का जो कोन्सेप्ट ईसमे लाया गया वो एैसा लगता हे की जेसे सरकार अपनी जिम्मेवारी से भाग रही है ओर टेक्स पेयर की तकलीफ बढा रही है. क्युकी अगर मे कीसीके साथ नियम अनुसार बीजनेस कर रहा हुं तो फीर मेरी चिंता गर्वमेन्ट को करवी चाहीएे. ईस मे तो ये हालात है की अगर मे कीसी व्यापारी से कुछ खरीद करता हुं तो वो टेक्स भरेगा की नही उस बात की चिंता मुजे ईतनी रहेती है,जेसे मेने उसके घर अपनी बेटी ब्याहनी हो.

CA Shivendra Hans Pandey
Baas Image 860
CA Shivendra Hans Pandey 5 years 1 month ago

Sir this is for e-way bill. Sir in order to have check on unregistered entities' transactions, in Tax Audit Report mandate to disclose all transactions without GST with HSN code and PAN of counter party. This would bound the entity and CA certifying to disclose such transactions. Now Using Data analytics the government can identify and trace all such transactions without GST and the entities doing so.
Baas Image 320
Rajesh Pandey 5 years 1 month ago

The whole justification for having e-way bill in earlier VAT era was the difference in the rates of VAT for the same item when it was sold within the same State (VAT = 13% or 14%) or when it is supplied to a different State (CST = 2%). Thus a trader had incentive to misdeclare the sale as inter-State.
In the Indian Model of GST, the GST rate on any item is same whether that item is supplied within the same State or it is supplied to a different State. Hence, e-way bill is not needed in GST era.
Baas Image 120
Sateesh Kumar Anthapu 5 years 1 month ago

Dear Sir,

Any administrative actions/policies will be effective provided there is an incentive for following the rules. The incentive for any honest tax payer is punishing people who doesn't adhere to it and use corrupt practices.

A salaried employee pays tax on income and again pays tax on every item he/she purchase. But a business man OR a farmer doesn't pay income tax. Govt should treat all income sources as same and tax accordingly instead of distinguishing on source of income.

Ramakrishnan Hariharan_1
Baas Image 320
Ramakrishnan Hariharan 5 years 1 month ago

Greetings from Ramakrishnan-Try to reduce by next budget the (Group-ReGroup)GST percentage slabs by 2 or 3 Maximum to clear the confusion presently in the GST issue presently.
Take away GST from Sanitary Napkins - immediately. (No Tax on Napkins if MRP per piece is say below 8-10 rupees). otherwise the invention will be waste. Moreover in 3 years IncomeTax department must be frozon/takenoff from India.
include the tax outgo in high end luxury items and large savings also - no problem.